Wednesday, March 9, 2011

Planting Seeds


We all bring our own experiences into a situation.  I believe our experiences are based on our history.  The idea of one's history can come into question very easily.  I've always been of the mindset that a history derives from experiences, being more specific, a person's perceptions of an experience.  The environment can have strong impacts on self, both consciously and unconsciously.  Others' experiences in relation to one's own life can also influence one's history.  I, by no means, am implying that someone else's experiences are your experiences, but I do have the understanding that a community--be it family, town, country, race, ethnicity, etc.--have a part in forming who one becomes within their own life and existence; therefore, that history becomes, in part, your history.  

I strong believe that blame does not pass through generations of a community or family as I am implying a history might.  One should not be blamed for another's actions.  Although, responsibility is another factor.  Future holders of a past become responsible for what their predecessors took part.  I say this in a specific context though.  One is not responsible for an apology, which goes into taking responsibility for the blame.  No blaming.  Responsibility does lie within education.  We must learn from our own people, whether it be our entire world's actions or our neighbor's actions.  

One simple conversation turned ground shattering.  When a lack of access to knowledge is withheld, the knowing community is not taking responsibility.  If a liberal, completely non-racist, pro-democratic, pro-grassroots, educated, and interested 35-year-old person understands there not to be a problem because, "There are no Jews here anymore," then we have a problem.  

Austrian history did not, "Start in 1950."

Light bulbs went off.  For me, yes.  For my other Jewish friend sitting beside me, yes.  But, for him - a spot light.  The absence of responsibility within a community led to a disillusionment for an educated person. " Yes, the problems with the Turkish immigrants interfering with a pure Austrian country is the same concept."  Yes, you completely disagree with this concept of pure Austrian country.  But, 35% of voting Austrians do agree.   No, you did not do anything; it was your grandfather's generation.  Yes, it still plays a part in your history, (in my opinion).  No, there is no blame placing.  Yes, we must educate and hear the stories.  Feel the emotion.  Learn from our past.  

If a middle-class, educated and interested social worker had never even been given the seed to consider his past a part of his countries and families, something could be wrong.  We need more conversations like the one last night.  
  
This was the first time this Austrian had ever knowingly met 2, non-Israeli, Jews. This first conversation planted a new seed.  We need many many more seeds. 


3 comments:

  1. dear rachl!

    i felt a kind of sorry, as is read your blog-post. i think it is important to talk about history, politics and many other things in the next time. i hope we can start that in the next days.
    i'm sorry, that i didn't realize your and emilys' jewish background. overall i didn't want to hurt no person in any kind.
    i want to add is some figures:
    the fpoe - the right-wing party in austria gained 17,5% at the last general elecations in 2008.
    http://wahl08.bmi.gv.at/
    according to an survey of today they have 27%:
    http://kurier.at/nachrichten/2080439.php
    i don't like the fpoe and i often have the feeling thatthey have/get 35% and i'm afraid that they get 35%.
    please help me/us to finde ways to avoid that!
    see you!
    david

    ReplyDelete
  2. hi rachel,

    i am really surprised how you interpretated some parts of our conversation. and i am especially surprised that i find words that i said in a blog now. i never said that austrian history started in 1950. i just said, that my history started in 1975 when i was born. and i think you took a few things that i have said and placed it in your blog out of the sence. i dont want to write about it here, but i hope we can talk about it next week...

    of course i am also sorry if i hurt you or emily, but next time please tell it to me personally.

    oh, one more thing i have to say, because i am afraid that people that read your blog will maybe think that i am a bad guy: yes i said that we almost have no jews in austria, but i cannot understand why we have a problem because i said that. i just told it to you as a fact!

    o.k., see you

    gerhard

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Gerhard,

    A few things... I, in no way at all, think you are a bad guy what-so-ever! And you have nothing to apologize for. I believe our conversation was wonderful. Needed. My point was that we need more conversations like this one. I believe in education, and what I believe our conversation did was open a new line of education on multiple levels. I believe more people should interact and talk the way we did. many many more. If we educate all sides, my vision resides that our world will be a much more peaceful and accepting place.

    I know I made this public, and hope very much you do not see this as a negative, but a step towards more positive.

    No, you did not say that Austrian history started in 1950. I was combining what you said with some other things I have heard. I am sorry I implied you stated that, when in fact, you did not.

    Again, I want to strongly say that you said nothing that hurt me, or Emily. We talked about this quite a bit that night, and found the conversation to be a wonderful dialogue in a very good direction. I was in fact inspired by your openness to learn and take in a different perspective. I believe you will make an excellent social worker, and you are the exact type of person our entire world needs.

    Thank you for allowing me to share my experiences with you. I thank you for sharing your insights with me.

    ReplyDelete